Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leon Liao's avatar

Excellent piece!

This essay implicitly acknowledges a fact that many American hawks remain reluctant to accept: the United States has already missed the window to prevent China from building a comprehensive semiconductor ecosystem.

The real question is now: How far behind the technological frontier will China remain—and for how long?

Where I am less convinced is the assumption that maintaining a lead at the frontier will automatically preserve America’s overall industrial dominance. China’s experience in high-speed rail, solar, batteries and EVs suggests that industrial leadership also depends on manufacturing scale, engineering speed and the depth of the wider ecosystem.

If semiconductors—especially AI chips—are increasingly becoming a form of systems competition, then cooperation may ultimately serve both countries better than an endless expansion of export controls. Unfortunately, that is precisely the conclusion many American hawks are least prepared to accept.

No posts

Ready for more?